Problem 1:
Nizar had been pronounced as the rightful MB in Perak, so he should be allowed to carry on his duty as a MB.
Zambry obtained an order for stay of execution of KL High Court’s decision, so Nizar can no longer carry on his duty as MB.
KL High Court’s decision remains good and intact, until being overturned by the Court of Appeal. The stay of execution does not in any way overturn the decision. So, Zambry is NOT the legitimate MB.
If Zambry is not the legitimate MB, he cannot enter MB office.
If there is a stay of execution, Nizar cannot enter MB office.
From 2 MBs in Perak, the People of Perak now have NO Menteri Besar.
Situation stalled.
Problem 2:
KL High Court pronounced Nizar as the rightful MB. Only a motion of no-confidence in the Dewan can remove him.
Zambry can only legitimatize himself by moving a motion of no-confidence against Nizar in the Dewan.
If Zambry moves a motion of no-confidence in the Dewan, it means Zambry is recognizing Nizar as the MB.
If Zambry moves a motion of no-confidence in the Dewan, it means Zambry admits he is not the MB.
If Zambry is not the MB, he should not occupy the MB office now.
As such, Zambry cannot move a motion of no-confidence against Nizar.
As such, Nizar cannot be removed.
Situation stalled.
Why cracking your head?
Why cracking your head? Dissolve the Assembly and return the mandate to the People.
In a democracy country, it is the People’s choice, not BN PR or the Court’s choice.
i understand your point of view. but, if this zambry finally admit nizar as MB & ask for an emergency state assembly & go for no confident move against nizar? how? i am sure the appeal BN made is just to buy time. but i am confuse here, why BN doesn's know the high court decision in advance? OR BN now is acting? haha....
ReplyDeleteI don't believe there is justice in our police and judiciary. You are a lawyer, you should know better (do you remember Kg. Gajah?)
ReplyDeleteWhere the hell in the Commanwealth world allows judiciary being manipulated by politicians at such a way? Thinking at this point, Malaysia is not far away from Zimbabwe, and getting far away from being 1st class nation.
'Gandhi' and the hooligans announced a secret weapon in a week's time, to completely wipe out PR from Perak.
Better be prepared. God bless you.
Politics and the courts in Malaysia have once again lived up to my expectations of providing me with comic relieve. Hardly watch comedies this days. I just follow the Malaysian news.
ReplyDeleteWhile it takes months for one appeal to be heard, the other took a matter of hours, by ONE judge no less. Looks like his pockets will be much more deeper now that he doesn't have to share with anyone else. Describing the Malaysian courts as a kangaroo court is an understatement really.
YB, why no update???
ReplyDelete